WHO recommends halving sugar intake advice

A standard can of sugar-sweetened soft drink would exceed the 5% limit on added sugars for most people

The World Health Organisation (WHO) has advised halving sugar intake advice from 10% of total calories to 5% of total calories in a new dietary guideline proposal.

The WHO said it would retain its earlier 2002 recommendation that added sugars should account for no more than 10% of total calories, but added that reducing consumption to 5% “would have additional benefits”.

In particular, it said papers published in the British Medical Journal (BMJ) and the Journal of Dental Research helped inform its proposal. The BMJ paper is a meta-analysis that links consumption of added sugars – but not other carbohydrates – with increased BMI (body mass index).  The other paper found that reducing added sugar consumption to less than 5% of total calories significantly reduced incidence of dental caries.

“There is increasing concern that consumption of free sugars, particularly in the form of sugar-sweetened beverages, may result in both reduced intake of foods containing more nutritionally adequate calories and an increase in total caloric intake, leading to an unhealthy diet, weight gain and increased risk of noncommunicable diseases (NCDs),” the WHO said.

“Also of great concern is the role free sugars play in the development of dental diseases, particularly dental caries. Dental diseases are the most prevalent NCDs globally.”

Less than one can of sugar-sweetened soft drink

The suggested limits apply to all sugars that are added by food manufacturers or by consumers, including sucrose (table sugar), isoglucose (known as high fructose corn syrup in the United States), honey, syrups and fruit concentrates, among others.

For an average, normal weight adult, cutting added sugars to 5% of total daily calories is equivalent to about 25 g or about six teaspoons of sugar. A standard can of soft drink may contain up to 40 g or 10 teaspoons of sugar.

Debate needed…

Director of regulation, science and health at the UK’s Food and Drink Federation (FDF), Barbara Gallani, stressed that the WHO guideline for total sugar intake remained at 10% of total calories.

“Where a conditional recommendation of a further reduction of sugars intake to below 5% of total energy is made, the report cautions that there is greater uncertainty about the quality of the underpinning science base,” she said. “WHO emphasise the need for ‘substantial debate and involvement of stakeholders before this recommendation can be adopted as policy’.”

Simon Capewell, Professor of Clinical Epidemiology at the University of Liverpool, UK, said: “A 5% target would reflect extensive scientific evidence linking excess sugars with obesity, diabetes, heart disease and common cancers (and rotten teeth in kids).

“Brits currently consume about three times too much sugar, 15% not 5%.”

The advice is open for consultation until March 31 and will be subject to a peer review process. The document – including instructions on how to comment – is available to download here.

Related News

The Sugar Debate: Separating Fact from Fiction

How does sugar affect health? Find out at FoodNavigator’s Sugar Debate: Separating Fact from Fiction

British Sugar welcomes WHO added sugar guidance – with a caveat

British Sugar welcomes WHO added sugar guidance – with a caveat

How rapidly can industry cut sugar?

Action on Sugar sketches sugar reduction plans

Mondelēz sets 'uncommunicated' sugar limits on new products, but will only consider a sugar reduction pledge if WHO revises its guidance

Mondelēz: ‘We may revisit sugar reduction target’, if WHO formalizes guidance

Sweetener promise? Tequila plant compound backed for diabetic sweetener use and blood sugar benefits

Sweetener promise? Tequila plant compound backed for diabetic sweetener use and blood sugar benefits

CAOBISCO has urged the World Health Organization to consider a 2010 EFSA opinion before halving recommended sugar intake

‘Scientific substantiation’ needed before WHO reduces sugar guidance, says CAOBISCO

"This is not the first study showing a correlation of soda intake to stroke, but the data in this study are especially cleanly dose-related" - Prof Marion Nestle, New York University

Sweetened beverages again linked to stroke risk, and effects could be dose-related, says new study

The warning label required on all sugary beverages would read:  “STATE OF CALIFORNIA SAFETY WARNING: Drinking beverages with added sugar contributes to obesity, diabetes, and tooth decay.”

CA soda warning label: commonsense or red-tape nightmare?

Sucrose vs. artificial sweeteners: examining energy intake & expenditure

Sucrose vs. artificial sweeteners: examining energy intake & expenditure

“Attempts to promote healthy diets will only work if the food systems underpinning them are put right,” warns UN Special Rapporteur Olivier De Schutter.

Battling unhealthy food requires tobacco-style response

EWG report: On average, 34% of the calories in children’s cereals come from sugar, with children's cereals and granolas containing 40% more sugar on average than adult cereals and twice that of oatmeal.

EWG slams added sugar in kids' cereals; Gen Mills says it's leading the way in sugar reduction

UCSF scientists found an association between sugar-sweetened soda consumption and telomere shortening across all age, race, income and education levels (Image: Jeanny/Flickr)

San Francisco study associates sugar-sweetened soda with cell aging

European isoglucose is made from either wheat or maize.

Isoglucose market still faces hurdles in Europe

Sugars intakes have increased in Dutch male adolescents, but reduced in other populations like Denmark, the US, UK and for Dutch females, according to a data review

Sugar intakes 'decreasing' or 'stable' globally, report finds

The plan includes tougher limits on all marketing to children - not just television advertising

EU eyes reformulation and marketing restrictions to cut childhood obesity

The WHO says the food industry and urban planners can make a difference to European childhood obesity rates

WHO decries ‘deadly’ promotion of cheap, convenient food

Smoke signals: Sugar industry needs to embrace moderation (like the rest of us)

Smoke signals: Sugar industry needs to embrace moderation (like the rest of us)

Sugar and obesity: AB Sugar says singling out sugar is 'misleading'

‘Misleading’ to single out sugar as a lead cause of obesity, says AB Sugar

The risk of dying from heart disease increased exponentially with the amount of added sugars consumed

Sugar consumption linked to heart disease death risk

'No reason' to replace fructose with glucose in commercial foods, finds study

'No reason' to replace fructose with glucose in commercial foods, finds study