Commission opens infraction proceedings against UK’s 'traffic light' label

The Commission has sent a formal letter to the UK, opening proceedings against the UK's 'traffic light' label, which could see the state facing court action.

The European Commission has formally opened infraction proceedings against the UK for its 'traffic light' food labelling system, giving the state two months to defend itself against business complaints.

The Commission has notified the UK with a formal letter, marking the first stage in the pre-litigation procedure, the final step of which could be referral to the European courts of justice with the possibility of fines.

Discussing the decision, a spokesperson for the Commission said: The Commission has decided to seek information from the UK about front-of-pack nutrition labelling requirement for pre-packed food products in the UK, following received complaints from food and retail companies and representative organisations asserting that the use of such labelling would negatively affect the marketing of several products.”

The spokesperson added: “The Commission fully shares the objective of public health and fight against obesity pursued by the recommendation of UK government.”

“However, as the guardian of the treaties, the Commission is looking for the most appropriate and the less trade restrictive means to achieve this objective, while preserving the achievements of the internal market and preventing obstacles to free movement of goods.”

Investigating complaints 

The decision follows an investigation by the Commission earlier this month into the compatibility of the UK’s so called ‘traffic light’ scheme - a voluntary front-of-pack labelling system introduced in the country by its Food Standards Agency (FSA) -  with EU law.

The system ranks four nutrition elements – sugars, fat, saturated fatty acids and salt – by assigning the colour red, green or amber, depending on content levels.

Supporters say the scheme provides consumers with a clear and understandable guide to nutrition.

Yet, as the Commission pointed out in its announcement, others had expressed concerns that: “The simplistic character of the traffic light scheme might in certain instances create some misconception as regards the qualities of certain foodstuffs, such as nuts, seeds, and oily fish where significant amounts of fat come from those ingredients and is naturally occurring.”

Critics said this was likely to make the“marketing of some products more difficult and thus hinder or impede trade between EU countries”, as well as hinder attempts to harmonise EU food law.

It has been suggested that this may apply in particular to Italian foodstuff like olive oil. 

Mutiny in the ranks? 

Responding to the decision, trade association FoodDrinkEurope said it had always expressed concern about an individual member state taking such an approach, as it may "generate a proliferation of different national voluntary schemes across Europe, which could fragment the EU Internal Market and cause confusion for consumers".  

Meanwhile, the wheels appear to be in motion for a similar colour-coded scheme in France

Related News

The Commission has initiated legal proceedings against the UK's traffic light system - so why aren't any other labelling schemes facing the same problem?

UK's traffic light label is 'negative', says Commission

Too many front-of-pack logos are problematic for business, says Unilever's Paul Whitehouse

WHO calls for standardised nutrition labelling

UK MEP says the traffic light label scheme adheres to all points laid out by the EU Food Information to Consumers Regulation

Don’t challenge UK traffic light label, make it EU-compulsory, MEP tells commissioners

Colour-coded schemes have been endorsed by major food companies, says BEUC

FIC regs ‘missed opportunity’ for mandatory front of pack labelling

The colour coding takes into account saturated fat, sugar, salt and calories – and in some circumstances protein, fibre, fruits, vegetables and nuts

French colour-coded nutrition labels hailed as ‘antidote to food marketing’

Red traffic light labels activated a part of the brain associated with self-control in food choice

Traffic light labels may improve self-control

Food should be labelled with how much exercise is required to expend its calories in order to help promote an active lifestyle. (© iStock.com)

Expert calls for activity icons that could help ‘reduce obesity rates’

The UK's front-of-pack labelling system has been the subject of an ongoing battle between it and other European countries, notably Italy.©iStock/Goldstock

MEPs raise concerns (again) in relation to traffic light labels

UK ‘traffic light’ labels could be taken to EU courts of justice

EU Commission could take UK and its ‘traffic light’ labels to courts of justice

French health minister proposes new preventative public health law, which could see the country adopting a similar nutrition labelling system to the UK's 'traffic light' scheme.

France considers ‘traffic light’ labelling as UK MEP hits back at EU threat of court case

STOP fussing over UK traffic light labelling

STOP fussing over UK traffic light labelling

Traffic light labelling infringes the internal market, claims Italy

Europeans challenge UK traffic light scheme

Clare Cheney gives traffic light labels the red light

Traffic light labels: 'not the answer to obesity'

Comments (2)

Vrono - 11 Oct 2014 | 10:14

What about trans fats?

The only useful labeling is that of sugar and trans fats.

11-Oct-2014 at 22:14 GMT

A.Sekker - 02 Oct 2014 | 09:19

Saturated fats

Saturated fats as something exceptionally bad? HELLO, UK, we're in the 21st century! Keep up with the news, the Ancel Keys "research" was refuted a number of times already! I hope at least that part does not prevail, or you'll be ingesting only palm oil in few years time on the Isles.

02-Oct-2014 at 21:19 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.