European RSPO 2014

Sustainable palm oil pressures worrying to emerging economies

Delegates at the European Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil debated sustainable palm oil in London this week

Food businesses and consumers don’t understand the impact emerging economies could face if pressure to source 100% sustainable palm oil builds too quickly, Marks & Spencer’s (M&S) sustainable development manager Fiona Wheatley claims.

“Green consumers have a tendency to focus on a single issue and don’t always understand that there’s an economy behind palm oil,” Wheatley told FoodManufacture.co.uk.

Most consumers didn’t know what palm oil was, despite retailers including M&S labelling it for years, she said at the European Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) in London earlier this week.

Impact on economies

But some knew what it was and would try to avoid buying products containing unsustainable palm oil and boycott those selling it or campaign to have its use stopped altogether, without understanding the complexities of its production and economic impact.

[While food businesses] tended to focus on their own supply chains and how they can further their use of responsible palm oil, they need to be looking at the bigger picture to try to scale up that intention,” she added. 

Whole economies relied on palm oil production to sustain their incomes, Indonesia’s vice minister of trade Dr Bayu Krisnamurthi told delegates at the RSPO.  

Some producer countries were worried that pressure from the western world to implement 100% sustainable palm oil supply chains as soon as 2015 was misguided and threatening, he added.

 ‘Can’t just stop trading’

“It’s not something that will happen overnight and at the same time, you can’t just stand still and stop trading palm oil while we wait to be trade certified [as sustainable],” said Krisnamurthi.

“We need to trade to make it a viable business while building [more sustainability] and that’s the biggest challenge we face today.”    

There was a blame culture in the western world that palm oil production was destroying rainforests, the planet and causing health issues, he said.

“But blaming palm oil for international health concerns and other issues is bad,” he added.

“Looking at the land use and blaming palm oil for the land use change is also bad, you did it in Europe 100- and 200-years ago and we have just come late. We are using our natural resources to produce something natural and profitable.”

85% of the world’s palm oil

Malaysia was also facing heavy pressure from the west to change the way it produced palm oil, delegates at the event heard.

But as Cynthia Ong, founder, executive director and ceo of Land Empowerment Animals and People, said, Malaysia and Indonesia produced 85% of the world’s palm oil.

“Trading palm oil is imperative to our nations and we’re just responding to an increasing global demand for palm oil,” said Ong.

More communities in Malaysia wanted to plant palm oil because they saw it as a viable income and a way to put food on their tables, she added.

That was a fact and it was going to happen, so the best option was to present those communities with a sustainable solution in the form of RSPO certification, said Ong.

“In Indonesia and Malaysia, palm oil is inextricable and we have to get used to that. There’s no way we can say no to palm oil. It’s our bread and butter; it puts food on the table and a roof over our heads.”

Related News

Food firms that don't use sustainable palm oil are at risk of being exposed online

Food firms risk exposure over non-sustainable palm oil

Cargill has called on the RSPO to renew its principals

RSPO needs to broaden its principles: Cargill

All NBPO palm oil is certified sustainable according to RSPO standards

Mystery shrouds New Britain Palm Oil takeover rumours

European RSPO on palm oil took place in London on June 4

Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil in pictures and quotes

New Britain Palm Oil supplies UK food manufacturers with sustainable palm oil

Sime Darby could take over New Britain Palm Oil

'No other vegetable oil can compete with palm in terms of efficiency. It is ten times more productive than soybean and seven times more productive then rapeseed,' said Dr Kalanithi Nesarentam of MPOB

Malaysia hopes to double palm oil production by 2020

Indonesia’s plantation war with foreign conglomerates continues

Indonesia’s plantation war with foreign conglomerates continues

Unilever hopes the entire global food industry will only be using guaranteed sustainable palm oil by 2020

Sustainable palm oil milestone in sight for Unilever

Sustainable reassurances are sought

FDF palm oil guide launched

Foodservice and catering pose the greatest challenges to sustainable palm oil

Palm oil: progress on sustainability, but challenges remain

UK manufacturers are working hard to source sustainable palm oil, according to a CSR boss

Progress on sustainable palm oil unfairly criticised

NBPO posted 'disappointing results' after a difficult year, said Panmure Gordon

New Britain Palm Oil reports ‘disappointing results’

Comments (1)

Ratzio - 13 Jun 2014 | 07:25

Bread and butter

There is something unspeakable about this colonialism on Indonesia and Malaysia. Granted, their forest, while theirs, is useful to the whole world (carbon purposes). But at the same time, they do need to "put bread on the table and a roof over their heads". I guess it is easier for us to judge, as we are not facing the same level of risk. When we face junk food, they fight hunger. We need to let them grow and prosper.

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.