Guest article

No future for chocolate if cocoa farmers are deep-rooted in poverty

Chocolate will no longer be an everyday indulgence unless the industry and all actors support the livelihoods of millions of cocoa farmers

Chocolate could become a small and expensive niche product unless we all do more to help cocoa farmers escape poverty, writes UTZ Certified executive director Han De Groot.

“The further from the tree, the better the revenues.“ I often heard this phrase while discussing inequalities in the cocoa or coffee sector. It suggests an imbalance that we should perhaps accept to exist?

Taking a trip to Ivory Coast is the best way to get in touch with reality.

Worlds apart

While visting Soubre, the heart of cocoa production in the country, my eyes were caught by the beauty of the 70 meter high ceiba trees. The UTZ certified producers received me with the traditional greeting ceremony “faire le feu,” in which people form a circle, rub the palms of their hands together, and then applaud to welcome the visitor.

Somehow I felt very close to these farmers since, just like them, I focus so much of my attention on cocoa. But in a way this is an illusion, because we are worlds apart from each other when it comes to poverty.

When the ceremony was over the producers approached me to share their experiences and concerns, and the message was clear: There is still too much poverty to have a decent and sustainable life.

Low economic returns and child labor

Today the cocoa farmer gets more attention than ever before .We eat more chocolate than ever before and the cocoa is cheap for us.

For the farmer, though, the price of producing cocoa is pretty high. The costs are also high for the environment: Soils are being eroded and deforestation of native forest is also an issue. For some children schooldays are being taken up by farm work.

The notion that the fundamentals of the cocoa supply chain are unstable is hardly disputed nowadays. And for some in the cocoa sector it is now a clear-cut decision: There cannot be a future for a sector that is built on extremely low economic returns, environmental degradation and the use of child labor.

Chocolate industry acts but farmers still poor

Can companies stimulate cocoa farmers’ economic development without jeopardizing their own economic interests? Can farmers and companies create a win-win situation?

Large industry partners such as Nestlé and Mars are investing to develop better seedlings for the sector. These days, the industry is contributing to serious child-labor remediation programs undertaken by agencies such as the International Cocoa Initiative. So, yes, efforts are already well underway. However, the question remains: is the impact visible? I am sorry to say it, but the answer is Yes and No.

Certified farmers benefit from training, and they get higher yields from their farms. More cooperatives are being set-up, and they are bringing greater benefits for their members. But, it must also be said, they are still poor.

Some children do not have a school in the village to attend. The road to the market is still bumpy or non-existent and farmers depend on a very small pool of traders to buy their production. Sons and daughters choose a life in the city, uncertain what it will bring to them, but apparently it looks more attractive than life in the rural area.

An expensive Christmas gift

Developing a more viable cocoa sector is certainly necessary and no doubt a win-win for the industry as well as farmers.

Thus, productivity needs to go up, and farmers must have their fair share of the benefits. If not, it’s no exaggeration to say that chocolate will soon develop into a small and expensive niche-product: a nice present for your mother-in-law for Christmas, but not something that can be enjoyed every day, and certainly not an industry that can support the livelihoods of millions. And that is not good for Nestlé and Mars either.

Related News

UTZ says new code will see child labor 'laisons' placed in communities in need. Photo credit: UTZ Certified

New UTZ code: Child labor ‘prevention’, climate changes, living wages and gender equality

Regional focus is needed to put sustainability promises in to practice

Regional focus is needed to put sustainability promises in to practice

Could raising the retail price of chocolate by 3% help cocoa farmers and the chocolate industry?

Paying the price of chocolate: Breaking cocoa farming's cycle of poverty

‘The use of child slave labor in the ivory Coast is a humanitarian tragedy,’ and chocolate companies could be held to account, says senior circuit judge. Photo Credit - Make Chocolate Fair

Nestlé, ADM and Cargill can’t escape liability for cocoa child slavery, rules court

CME Group's cocoa futures contracts to compete with ICE's Liffe

Cocoa futures denominated in euros provides ease of access, says CME Group

At what price? Chocolate industry cocoa sustainability efforts miss core of the problem: Extreme poverty. Photo Credit: Oxfam America

Extreme poverty ignored in sustainable cocoa drive, say NGOs

Short-term sourcing deals hamper cocoa sustainability efforts, warns Ivorian cooperative. Photo credit: Eric St-Pierre

Who’s drawn the short straw? Chocolate makers can’t expect higher cocoa yields under short-term contracts

Cocoa procurement firms should not be ignored in sustainable cocoa drive, writes Finatrade. Photo credit: Finatrade

A different perspective: Cocoa Buyers must be incentivised to improve chocolate supply chain

Puratos Grand-Place aims to bridge wealth gap with Chocolate Bonus for cocoa farmers

Chocolate industry should embrace anti-extreme poverty tax, says Puratos Grand-Place

Cocoa farmers implement industry sustainability programs so ‘should not be the outsiders’, says newly formed International CoCoa Farmers Organization

The outsiders: Cocoa farmer voice missing in chocolate industry productivity push, says ICCFO

90% missed: Half a century to reach forgotten cocoa farming majority unless industry sources directly and talks price, says ICCFO

Cocoa sustainability to take 50 more years without step change: ICCFO

Social movement Cacao for Change calls for insurance protection for cocoa farmers under a new ‘shared value’ model it says should be adopted by the entire industry. Photo: iStock - Duncan_Andison

Cocoa ‘a sad story’: Farmers need insurance as human cost of industry overlooked, says Cacao for Change

Certification equips farmers to lead better lives and to tackle the global cocoa deficit: UTZ Certified

UTZ: Certification is our weapon against cocoa deficit

Mars, Ferrero and Hershey sustainable cocoa pledges increase sales of UTZ Certified cocoa

UTZ Certified cocoa volumes double after industry commitments

UTZ Certified says its policy of no minimum price for cocoa farmers avoids market distortion, while Fairtrade International says a minumum price protects farmers. Photo Credit: UTZ Certified

Cocoa certification: Does a minimum price distort the market or protect the farmer?

Related Products

See more related products